[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"grammar-exercise-01a1c61d-8945-7128-a1c2-944d335b5f91":3,"grammar-exercise-lesson-01a1c61d-80e9-766d-ae64-3a399e3f7b9e":243},{"id":4,"grammarPage":5,"title":6,"instructions":7,"seoTitle":8,"seoDescription":9,"displayOrder":10,"type":11,"questions":12,"ogImageUrl":242},"01a1c61d-8945-7128-a1c2-944d335b5f91","\u002Fapi\u002Fgrammar_pages\u002F01a1c61d-80e9-766d-ae64-3a399e3f7b9e","分清反問嘅前提同推論範圍","睇清楚對話同補充資料，揀出符合上下文嘅講法。唔好單靠疑問詞或者句末語氣詞判斷。","反問式條件練習：分清前提同推論範圍","呢組反問式條件選詞填空練習，用訂房、招聘、維修同社區活動等對話，練習分清真問題同反問、暫借前提同接受事實，以及質疑推論同否定事實嘅分別，留意上下文提供嘅線索。你會按講者立場判斷反問針對事實定係必然關係，理解「如果照你咁講」同「既然係咁」嘅分別，並檢查新資料可唔可以改變原先結論，避免將強烈語氣當成證據。",0,"word_select",[13,35,53,71,90,109,128,147,166,185,204,223],{"id":14,"sentenceTemplate":15,"displayOrder":10,"explanation":16,"exampleSentence":17,"blanks":18},"01a1c61d-8945-73a8-a1c2-944d35bc27e8","甲：如果佢連會都冇出席，仲點代表我哋發言呀？乙：佢事前收齊咗我哋嘅意見，我哋亦簽咗授權書。甲嘅推論要成立，就要接受邊個前提？__1__。","甲由冇出席推到唔可以代表大家，暗中將出席當成必要條件。出席就有資格係另一個方向嘅推論；獲授權者未必出席則容許乙提出嘅反例，唔係甲所依賴嘅前提。","「連簡介會都冇去，仲點帶隊？」將出席簡介會當成帶隊嘅必要條件，但要再睇有冇其他準備途徑。",[19],{"id":20,"blankNumber":21,"options":22},"01a1c61d-8945-7344-a1c2-944d35747c7e",1,[23,27,31],{"id":24,"optionText":25,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-72b0-a1c2-944d33d43e17","出席今次會議就足以取得代表資格",false,{"id":28,"optionText":29,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-72f0-a1c2-944d344dad2f","出席今次會議係代表大家發言嘅必要條件",true,{"id":32,"optionText":33,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-731c-a1c2-944d353d948a","獲得授權嘅人未必有出席今次會議",2,{"id":36,"sentenceTemplate":37,"displayOrder":21,"explanation":38,"exampleSentence":39,"blanks":40},"01a1c61d-8945-74a8-a1c2-944d3896418a","甲：張入場證唔見咗，可以點補領？職員：今次冇補領安排，只認呢張證，冇證一律唔准入。甲：咁張證唔見咗，我仲點入場呀？職員：所以請你保管好。甲前後兩個問題嘅作用係__1__。","第一句問補領方法；職員交代冇得補領、冇證唔准入場之後，甲用「仲點」指出規定帶嚟嘅後果。最後嘅提醒承接呢個後果，冇提供補領步驟。","最後一班船已經開走，又冇其他交通工具，今晚仲點返個島呀？",[41],{"id":42,"blankNumber":21,"options":43},"01a1c61d-8945-746c-a1c2-944d38325c1e",[44,47,50],{"id":45,"optionText":46,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-7400-a1c2-944d36669717","先問處理辦法，再質疑職員有冇講過規定",{"id":48,"optionText":49,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-7428-a1c2-944d36f3fbe7","先指出入唔到場，再請職員提供補領步驟",{"id":51,"optionText":52,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-744c-a1c2-944d376e3f61","先問處理辦法，再指出規定之下入唔到場",{"id":54,"sentenceTemplate":55,"displayOrder":34,"explanation":56,"exampleSentence":57,"blanks":58},"01a1c61d-8945-7590-a1c2-944d3a1faf25","阿珊話：如果條橋封咗，又冇其他路，我哋仲點送貨呀？同事隨即出示啱啱批出嘅通行安排，證明送貨車仍然可以過橋。阿珊原先暗示送唔到貨嘅判斷__1__。","新安排顯示送貨車可以行原本條橋，反駁咗冇路送貨嘅前提。冇其他路唔足以維持原判斷；改用陳述句亦唔會令已受反例挑戰嘅判斷成立。","「冇鎖匙仲點開門？」呢個判斷，要睇埋有冇其他獲准開門嘅方法。",[59],{"id":60,"blankNumber":21,"options":61},"01a1c61d-8945-7554-a1c2-944d39b7f863",[62,65,68],{"id":63,"optionText":64,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-74f0-a1c2-944d38b0835d","可以畀新資料推翻",{"id":66,"optionText":67,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-7514-a1c2-944d3977fd7f","因為冇其他路而仍然成立",{"id":69,"optionText":70,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-7534-a1c2-944d39793140","只要改成直接陳述就仍然成立",{"id":72,"sentenceTemplate":73,"displayOrder":74,"explanation":75,"exampleSentence":76,"blanks":77},"01a1c61d-8945-7670-a1c2-944d3c7dae33","主管話：如果連地址都未核對，仲點寄出通知呀？呢個反問將核對地址呈現成__1__。",3,"「連……都未……，仲點……」將前項放喺最低要求嘅位置。呢度地址仲未核對，唔係已經完成；句子亦唔係叫人寄出之後先核對。","如果連工具都未準備好，仲點開始維修呀？",[78],{"id":79,"blankNumber":21,"options":80},"01a1c61d-8945-7638-a1c2-944d3bf707b4",[81,84,87],{"id":82,"optionText":83,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-75d8-a1c2-944d3a39e3ef","通知寄出之後先要做嘅事",{"id":85,"optionText":86,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-75fc-a1c2-944d3a4e526a","寄出通知之前嘅起碼要求",{"id":88,"optionText":89,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-761c-a1c2-944d3b0e29dc","已經完成而毋須再理嘅事",{"id":91,"sentenceTemplate":92,"displayOrder":93,"explanation":94,"exampleSentence":95,"blanks":96},"01a1c61d-8945-7768-a1c2-944d3f77b77c","甲：預約少過五人就唔開班，今班得四人。乙：如果按呢條規定，咁今班咪開唔成囉？甲：係，你理解得啱。乙：好，我照呢個結果通知學員。乙嘅「咪……囉」用嚟__1__。",4,"乙喺甲確認之後按結果通知學員，對話顯示佢核對咗規定嘅應用。乙冇要求例外，亦冇質疑人數；「咪……囉」喺呢度唔帶反駁作用。","「每張券可以換兩杯，咁兩張咪換到四杯囉？」「冇錯。」",[97],{"id":98,"blankNumber":21,"options":99},"01a1c61d-8945-7730-a1c2-944d3f17906c",[100,103,106],{"id":101,"optionText":102,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-76cc-a1c2-944d3d0772c7","要求甲為今班加一個例外",{"id":104,"optionText":105,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-76f0-a1c2-944d3deaf1ab","質疑四人呢個預約數字",{"id":107,"optionText":108,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-7710-a1c2-944d3e19aaf5","確認按規定推出嘅結果",{"id":110,"sentenceTemplate":111,"displayOrder":112,"explanation":113,"exampleSentence":114,"blanks":115},"01a1c61d-8945-7848-a1c2-944d41f02215","甲：任何人請假都唔可以領全勤獎。乙：如果照呢條規定，咁代表公司出外受訓而請假嘅人咪都冇獎囉？呢個結果對佢哋唔公平。乙用反問__1__。",5,"後句明講結果唔公平，令前面嘅「咪……囉」成為反駁嘅一步。乙正正指出規定涵蓋呢類請假，唔係否認涵蓋。","如果所有借出嘅書都唔准續借，咁長期住院嘅讀者咪都要趕返嚟還囉？呢點值得再傾。",[116],{"id":117,"blankNumber":21,"options":118},"01a1c61d-8945-780c-a1c2-944d417d5856",[119,122,125],{"id":120,"optionText":121,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-77ac-a1c2-944d3fed9654","突出規定會帶嚟嘅問題",{"id":123,"optionText":124,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-77d0-a1c2-944d406cd462","表示完全贊成取消佢哋嘅獎",{"id":126,"optionText":127,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-77f0-a1c2-944d40beea3f","否認規定涵蓋受訓請假",{"id":129,"sentenceTemplate":130,"displayOrder":131,"explanation":132,"exampleSentence":133,"blanks":134},"01a1c61d-8945-792c-a1c2-944d4587233a","甲：我主張投訴人要公開姓名，否則唔受理。乙：如果照你咁講，怕報復而匿名投訴嘅人咪都冇得投訴囉？甲：你唔接受呢個後果？乙：唔接受，呢條規則要再傾。乙用「如果照你咁講」，喺呢段對話入面係__1__。",6,"準則由甲提出，乙沿用佢推到匿名投訴被拒嘅後果，再要求重議。呢度唔係承接雙方議定嘅規則，亦唔係問甲講過乜。「既然係咁」本身亦可以用喺反駁中，唔可以單靠換標記就判錯。","如果照你咁講，所有改期申請都唔批，咁因病入院嘅人咪都冇例外囉？",[135],{"id":136,"blankNumber":21,"options":137},"01a1c61d-8945-78f4-a1c2-944d44a80446",[138,141,144],{"id":139,"optionText":140,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-7890-a1c2-944d42a7944e","用「既然係咁」承接雙方已議定嘅準則，再安排執行",{"id":142,"optionText":143,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-78b4-a1c2-944d439587d8","借甲提出嘅準則推演後果，再提出異議",{"id":145,"optionText":146,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-78d4-a1c2-944d4436e240","追問甲有冇提出過呢條準則，再核對原話",{"id":148,"sentenceTemplate":149,"displayOrder":150,"explanation":151,"exampleSentence":152,"blanks":153},"01a1c61d-8945-7a0c-a1c2-944d482379e8","協商會上，承辦商話：我哋可以今日補齊維修報價，想請你哋再考慮。主席要直接講出暫緩批款嘅理由，同時交代重新考慮嘅條件。佢應該點接話？__1__",7,"正確講法直接連起未核實費用同暫緩建議，再交代收到報價後重議。第一項仍然用反問引導答案；第二項終止申請，冇保留重新考慮嘅條件。","交貨日期仲未確認，所以我建議暫時唔簽；等供應商回覆之後再傾。",[154],{"id":155,"blankNumber":21,"options":156},"01a1c61d-8945-79d0-a1c2-944d47afefe8",[157,160,163],{"id":158,"optionText":159,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-7970-a1c2-944d4613df25","如果連維修費用都未核實，仲點批款呀？收到報價再傾啦。",{"id":161,"optionText":162,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-7994-a1c2-944d470fc694","維修費用仲未核實，所以我建議結束今次申請；收到報價亦唔再評估。",{"id":164,"optionText":165,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-79b4-a1c2-944d4751d6c0","維修費用仲未核實，所以我建議暫緩批款；收到報價之後再一齊評估。",{"id":167,"sentenceTemplate":168,"displayOrder":169,"explanation":170,"exampleSentence":171,"blanks":172},"01a1c61d-8945-7af4-a1c2-944d4bae5273","甲：佢做過大公司，一定識帶團隊。乙：我知道佢確實做過大公司，但唔通做過大公司，就一定識帶團隊咩？乙質疑嘅係__1__。",8,"乙先承認工作經歷，再用「唔通……就一定……咩」質疑由經歷跳到能力嘅必然推論，唔係否定經歷或者所有人嘅能力。","我承認佢讀過設計，但唔通讀過設計，就一定識整網站咩？",[173],{"id":174,"blankNumber":21,"options":175},"01a1c61d-8945-7abc-a1c2-944d4af04dee",[176,179,182],{"id":177,"optionText":178,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-7a50-a1c2-944d4900bc78","呢段經歷係咪足以保證帶隊能力",{"id":180,"optionText":181,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-7a7c-a1c2-944d49413df3","佢係咪真係做過大公司",{"id":183,"optionText":184,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-7a9c-a1c2-944d4a3c9cde","所有做過大公司嘅人都冇帶隊能力",{"id":186,"sentenceTemplate":187,"displayOrder":188,"explanation":189,"exampleSentence":190,"blanks":191},"01a1c61d-8945-7bd4-a1c2-944d4fa59a61","甲話新同事唔識用呢部機。乙指住新同事獨立操作嘅紀錄反問：唔通佢唔識用咩？乙呢次直接質疑嘅係__1__。",9,"反問直接包含「佢唔識用」呢個判斷，乙用紀錄支持自己對呢個判斷嘅懷疑。佢唔係質疑操作經歷，亦冇反問操作經歷係咪足以保證能力。","佢啱啱先幫大家翻譯完，唔通佢唔識英文咩？",[192],{"id":193,"blankNumber":21,"options":194},"01a1c61d-8945-7b98-a1c2-944d4ed03796",[195,198,201],{"id":196,"optionText":197,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-7b3c-a1c2-944d4c470c82","新同事曾經操作部機呢個判斷",{"id":199,"optionText":200,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-7b5c-a1c2-944d4d0f2bdb","新同事唔識用部機呢個判斷",{"id":202,"optionText":203,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-7b7c-a1c2-944d4ddfd25f","操作過部機就足以保證識用呢個推論",{"id":205,"sentenceTemplate":206,"displayOrder":207,"explanation":208,"exampleSentence":209,"blanks":210},"01a1c61d-8945-7cb4-a1c2-944d51b3872a","甲承認呢間旅館收費高，但反問：唔通收費高，就一定服務好咩？單憑呢句反問，甲__1__。",10,"質疑「高收費必然帶嚟好服務」，唔等於保證相反結果。甲亦已經承認收費高，唔可以解讀成否認前項。","唔通用新器材，就一定拍得好咩？呢句唔等於話用新器材一定拍得差。",[211],{"id":212,"blankNumber":21,"options":213},"01a1c61d-8945-7c78-a1c2-944d51a75cc3",[214,217,220],{"id":215,"optionText":216,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-7c18-a1c2-944d4fb7ee7c","已經證明間旅館服務一定差",{"id":218,"optionText":219,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-7c38-a1c2-944d4fe576cb","已經否認間旅館收費高",{"id":221,"optionText":222,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-7c58-a1c2-944d50e4a6d7","冇保證間旅館服務一定差",{"id":224,"sentenceTemplate":225,"displayOrder":226,"explanation":227,"exampleSentence":228,"blanks":229},"01a1c61d-8945-7d90-a1c2-944d5379f197","甲：只要換個包裝，銷量就必然上升。乙想針對「必然」，唔係否認銷量有上升嘅可能：唔通換個包裝，銷量就__1__上升咩？",11,"甲聲稱必然上升，乙要質疑呢個保證，所以保留「一定」。「有可能」會將質疑轉向可能性；「未必會」則將非必然性放入反問範圍，唔符合乙指定嘅立場。","唔通加多一班車，就一定解決到繁忙時間嘅問題咩？",[230],{"id":231,"blankNumber":21,"options":232},"01a1c61d-8945-7d58-a1c2-944d53356fc3",[233,236,239],{"id":234,"optionText":235,"isCorrect":30,"displayOrder":10},"01a1c61d-8945-7cf8-a1c2-944d51cea8c6","一定會",{"id":237,"optionText":238,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":21},"01a1c61d-8945-7d18-a1c2-944d527b0c38","有可能",{"id":240,"optionText":241,"isCorrect":26,"displayOrder":34},"01a1c61d-8945-7d3c-a1c2-944d52c928ba","未必會","\u002Fuploads\u002Fimages\u002Fgpimg_c556aab3-a7f0-4a15-880b-38dea1e344ea_hero.webp?v=1794325186",{"title":244,"slug":245,"language":246,"level":247},"反問式條件同論證","faanman-tiugin","yue","C2"]