[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"grammar-page-yue-faanman-laapcoeng":3,"grammar-exercises-by-page-01a1c61d-80e4-78a5-8d8f-40c617cba18b":123,"exercise-list-path-yue-none":141},{"id":4,"title":5,"slug":6,"seoDescription":7,"content":8,"language":9,"level":10,"displayOrder":11,"grammarTopics":12,"createdAt":18,"updatedAt":19,"totalExercises":17,"vocabularyLists":20,"readyImages":122},"01a1c61d-80e4-78a5-8d8f-40c617cba18b","反問同預設立場","faanman-laapcoeng","掌握廣東話反問點樣表達反對、強調同要求認同，分清真心求答案、帶住預期答案同預設事實嘅問句。透過日常對話，理解唔通、邊有、點會、仲唔同咩嘅作用，留意否定詞、上下文同語氣點樣影響意思，學識指出唔接受嘅前提，避免未了解清楚就指責人，並按對話關係揀較合適嘅講法，令立場清楚之餘，亦畀對方解釋嘅空間。","## 1. 問句入面嘅立場\n\n有時你用問句，唔係因為唔知答案，而係想對方認同你、重新諗吓，或者聽出你嘅不滿。呢類**反問**要連埋情境理解。你亦會學點樣分清反問、帶住某個答案傾向嘅問句，同埋將某件事當成已知事實嘅問句。\n\n學完之後，你可以：\n\n- 聽出問句暗示緊邊個答案；\n- 用反問表達反對或者強調；\n- 指出問句入面你唔接受嘅假設。\n\n## 2. 反問唔係真係要你提供資料\n\n普通問句主要係想知道答案；反問就主要係表達立場。**同一句說話，可以因為上下文同語調唔同而有唔同用途。**\n\n:::example\n**真係問地點：**你第一次嚟呢區，想買早餐。\n\n「附近**邊度有麵包舖呀**？」\n\n**反問：**你哋行遍附近幾條街，全部都係工廠，朋友仲叫你去買新鮮麵包。\n\n「呢度**邊度有麵包舖呀**？」\n\n後一句主要係話：呢度根本冇麵包舖，買唔到。\n:::\n\n判斷嗰陣，唔好淨係睇疑問詞。要睇講者係咪真係缺少資料，定係已經有答案，想藉住問句強調出嚟。\n\n## 3. 常見反問點樣暗示答案\n\n以下句式喺適當情境下，會令某個答案顯得理所當然。不過，唔係一見到呢啲字就一定係反問。\n\n| 句式 | 情境同例句 | 暗示嘅立場 |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| **唔通……咩？** | 已經冇車返屋企：唔通我哋要行返去咩？ | 講者覺得行返去唔合理，想搵其他辦法。 |\n| **邊有……呀？** | 工作排得密密麻麻：我邊有時間去旅行呀？ | 我冇時間去旅行。 |\n| **點會……呀？** | 對方懷疑你唔記得佢：我點會唔記得你呀？ | 我梗係記得你。 |\n| **仲唔……？** | 對方問夠唔夠人手：已經有十個人幫手，仲唔夠？ | 講者認為應該夠。 |\n\n留意否定詞嘅範圍。**我點會唔記得你呀？**否定嘅係「唔記得」呢個可能，所以表達嘅係「記得」，唔係「唔記得」。\n\n:::note\n反問表達嘅係講者嘅立場，唔代表嗰個立場一定啱。聽者仍然可以反駁，例如：「十個人都唔夠，因為今日有三百個客。」\n:::\n\n## 4. 帶住預期答案，未必就係反問\n\n**咩**可以表達驚訝或者質疑，反映講者原本有另一個想法。但講者仍然可能真係想知道答案。\n\n:::example\n**情境：**你一直以為阿欣今日放假，突然見到佢着住制服。\n\n你：「你今日要返工**咩**？」\n\n阿欣：「係呀，我同同事調咗更。」\n\n你原本以為佢唔使返工，但呢句仍然係真誠嘅確認問題。\n:::\n\n再比較：\n\n- **你今日要返工呀？**：喺呢個情境下，可以係見到制服之後作出確認。\n- **你今日要返工咩？**：更明顯表達「同我原本以為嘅唔同」。\n\n:::warning\n唔好將所有帶**咩**嘅問句都當成反問，亦唔好將**咩**當成冇意思嘅問號。佢會影響聽者點樣理解你原本嘅想法同而家嘅反應。\n:::\n\n## 5. 問句可以將未同意嘅事當成事實\n\n除咗暗示答案，問句仲可以帶有**預設**：講者問緊一樣嘢，同時將另一樣嘢當成已經成立。\n\n例如，**你點解又遲到呀？**問嘅係原因，但句中已經將「你今次遲到」當成事實；**又**仲帶出以前亦發生過同類情況。\n\n| 問句 | 問緊乜嘢 | 當成已經成立嘅事 |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| 你點解遲到呀？ | 遲到嘅原因 | 你今次遲到。 |\n| 你點解又遲到呀？ | 今次遲到嘅原因 | 你今次遲到，而且之前亦遲到過。 |\n\n如果你唔接受呢個前提，唔使直接答原因。你可以先指出邊部分唔啱。\n\n:::example\n甲：「你點解**又遲到**呀？」\n\n乙：「我今次係遲到，不過之前嗰幾次我都準時，唔係『又遲到』。」\n\n乙接受今次遲到，但唔接受「之前亦遲到過」呢個講法。\n:::\n\n想避免未了解清楚就指責人，可以先問：「你今日係咪遲到呀？」確認咗之後，再問發生咩事。\n\n## 6. 用之前，先諗語氣同關係\n\n反問可以令立場更鮮明，但亦可能令人覺得你唔畀佢解釋。例如，同事提出一個安排，你答**「咁點得呀？」**，主要係否定個安排；如果你想一齊解決問題，可以講：「咁安排可能唔夠時間，我哋可唔可以改早啲？」\n\n你可以用以下三步檢查：\n\n1. **係咪真係想知道答案？** 係嘅話，唔好單靠反問表達。\n2. **暗示緊邊個答案？** 睇清楚否定詞，亦要配合上下文。\n3. **有冇將未確認嘅事當成事實？** 有嘅話，先確認；聽到唔合理嘅預設，亦可以先澄清。\n\n記住：**反問係用問句表達立場；帶住預期答案嘅問題仍然可以真係求答案；預設就係問句背後當成已知嘅事。**","yue","B2",133,[13],{"id":14,"name":5,"level":10,"language":9,"isCompleted":15,"completionPercentage":16,"totalExercises":17,"completedExercises":16},"01a1c61d-7fcf-76d4-a07f-b7e8515487f7",false,0,2,"2026-11-10T15:39:44+00:00","2026-11-10T17:56:44+00:00",[21],{"id":22,"title":5,"vocabularyListWords":23,"isPublished":37},"01a1c61d-c82a-73f8-ba44-d6f1670d1597",[24,39,52,68,83,102],{"id":25,"vocabularyWord":26,"displayOrder":38},"01a1c61d-c82a-7450-ba44-d6f16783ca30",{"id":27,"word":28,"frequency":29,"level":30,"language":9,"partsOfSpeech":31,"audio":15},"01a1c61d-a99e-7330-8987-fb0410b6c8c6","唔通",7,"B1",[32],{"id":33,"partOfSpeech":34,"definition":35,"exampleSentences":36,"isPrimary":37,"meaningOrder":38},"01a1c696-3228-7e61-8199-3674c8714c8d","ADVERB","用喺反問句入面，表示講嘅人覺得某件事好難令人相信，或者唔應該係咁，帶有驚訝、懷疑或者質問嘅語氣，通常好似「難道」咁。","你成日遲到，唔通你唔知道老細會嬲咩？\n佢咁叻，唔通呢條題目都做唔到咩？\n天氣咁差，唔通你仲想出街咩？",true,1,{"id":40,"vocabularyWord":41,"displayOrder":17},"01a1c61d-c82a-7480-ba44-d6f1684b7278",{"id":42,"word":43,"frequency":44,"level":45,"language":9,"partsOfSpeech":46,"audio":15},"01a1c61d-a92f-7932-b78e-42b56e8cfbad","邊有",8,"A2",[47],{"id":48,"partOfSpeech":49,"definition":50,"exampleSentences":51,"isPrimary":37,"meaningOrder":38},"01a1c696-3026-7932-b404-1bf442509de8","PHRASE","用嚟反問嘅說法，意思係「點會有」、「邊度有」，表示覺得完全冇可能，語氣好強，通常用嚟唔同意、唔相信或者抱怨。成個「邊有」都要一齊用，後面通常跟住一件事或者一個情況。","邊有人成日食快餐都唔肥嘅？\n邊有咁抵嘅事！畀咗錢都冇嘢攞。\n你話佢唔識講英文？邊有可能啊，佢喺外國讀書㗎。\n邊有咁易啊，我學咗三年都未識。",{"id":53,"vocabularyWord":54,"displayOrder":67},"01a1c61d-c82a-74a8-ba44-d6f16936c4eb",{"id":55,"word":56,"frequency":57,"level":45,"language":9,"partsOfSpeech":58,"audio":15},"01a1c61d-a97f-780d-8917-bf3095d70d2f","點會",9,[59,63],{"id":60,"partOfSpeech":49,"definition":61,"exampleSentences":62,"isPrimary":37,"meaningOrder":38},"01a1c696-3226-7ee5-9373-8085621a0fa5","用嚟反問，意思係「點可能會」，表示講嘅人覺得件事絕對唔會發生，或者唔應該發生。","我點會唔記得你生日呢？\n佢咁叻，點會輸畀我哋呀？\n我哋咁好朋友，我點會呃你㗎？",{"id":64,"partOfSpeech":49,"definition":65,"exampleSentences":66,"isPrimary":15,"meaningOrder":17},"01a1c696-3226-7f31-9373-8085627f5ab5","用嚟問原因，意思似「點解會」，表示對一件事感到奇怪，想知道點解會咁。","你點會識佢嘅？\n今日點會咁多人嘅？\n呢度點會有隻貓喺度呢？",3,{"id":69,"vocabularyWord":70,"displayOrder":82},"01a1c61d-c82a-74c8-ba44-d6f169f92da4",{"id":71,"word":72,"frequency":44,"level":45,"language":9,"partsOfSpeech":73,"audio":15},"01a1c61d-a841-78f3-a466-9209c0fdbe7f","仲唔",[74,78],{"id":75,"partOfSpeech":49,"definition":76,"exampleSentences":77,"isPrimary":37,"meaningOrder":38},"01a1c696-2e72-7269-92b8-19444f61112f","用喺問句或者反問入面，意思係「仲未」或者「點解仲未」，表示講嘅人覺得件事應該已經發生，或者應該要做，但係對方仲未做，帶少少催促或者驚訝嘅語氣。","十二點喇，你仲唔瞓？\n啲嘢食都凍晒喇，仲唔食？\n就嚟遲到喇，仲唔出門口？",{"id":79,"partOfSpeech":49,"definition":80,"exampleSentences":81,"isPrimary":15,"meaningOrder":17},"01a1c696-2e72-72b1-92b8-194450088d50","用嚟叫人快啲做某件事，意思係「仲唔快啲」，帶催促嘅語氣，通常後面會跟動詞。","老師喺度等緊你，仲唔快啲入嚟？\n落雨喇，仲唔收衫？\n人哋同你講聲多謝，你仲唔回應下佢？",4,{"id":84,"vocabularyWord":85,"displayOrder":101},"01a1c61d-c82a-74e8-ba44-d6f16a8f1912",{"id":86,"word":87,"frequency":88,"level":89,"language":9,"partsOfSpeech":90,"audio":15},"01a1c61d-a628-7c94-9f68-4f42d6ed373c","咩",10,"A1",[91,96],{"id":92,"partOfSpeech":93,"definition":94,"exampleSentences":95,"isPrimary":37,"meaningOrder":38},"01a1c696-2968-7b19-8581-6df148d73392","PRONOUN","疑問代詞，問「乜嘢」嘅意思，通常用喺「做咩」、「咩事」、「咩人」呢類說法入面，問原因、事情或者人物。","你做咩喊呀？\n咩事呀？你點解咁嬲？\n你想食咩呀？",{"id":97,"partOfSpeech":98,"definition":99,"exampleSentences":100,"isPrimary":15,"meaningOrder":17},"01a1c696-2968-7b61-8581-6df14922c777","PARTICLE","句尾語氣助詞，放喺句尾表示驚訝、懷疑或者唔相信，同時帶有反問嘅意思，等於問「真係咁咩？」。","你唔識游水咩？\n佢走咗咩？我冇見到喎。\n今日唔使返工咩？",5,{"id":103,"vocabularyWord":104,"displayOrder":121},"01a1c61d-c82a-7504-ba44-d6f16a9eaf50",{"id":105,"word":106,"frequency":88,"level":89,"language":9,"partsOfSpeech":107,"audio":15},"01a1c61d-a61e-7560-9239-f8d44173d01c","呀",[108,112,116],{"id":109,"partOfSpeech":98,"definition":110,"exampleSentences":111,"isPrimary":37,"meaningOrder":38},"01a1c696-2967-7dec-9029-74e3ae4db020","句尾語氣詞，用嚟令句子聽落柔和、親切啲，成日用喺問問題、叫人或者講嘢嘅時候，等語氣自然啲。","你今日去邊度呀？\n食咗飯未呀？\n佢係咪你嘅朋友呀？",{"id":113,"partOfSpeech":98,"definition":114,"exampleSentences":115,"isPrimary":15,"meaningOrder":17},"01a1c696-2967-7e30-9029-74e3af0cff85","放喺句尾或者稱呼後面，用嚟叫人、提醒人或者表示驚訝、感嘆嘅語氣詞。","阿媽呀，我返到嚟喇！\n好靚呀！\n快啲啦，遲到呀！",{"id":117,"partOfSpeech":118,"definition":119,"exampleSentences":120,"isPrimary":15,"meaningOrder":67},"01a1c696-2967-7e80-9029-74e3af3841aa","INTERJECTION","表示驚訝、痛楚或者忽然醒起嘅叫聲。","呀！我唔見咗個銀包！\n呀，好痛呀！\n呀，我記起喇，佢今日唔喺度。",6,[],[124,134],{"@id":125,"@type":126,"id":127,"grammarPage":128,"title":129,"instructions":130,"displayOrder":16,"type":131,"questionCount":132,"blankCount":132,"isCompleted":15,"ogImageUrl":133},"\u002Fapi\u002Fgrammar_exercises\u002F01a1c61d-891c-763c-aa90-d863be26dada","GrammarExercise","01a1c61d-891c-763c-aa90-d863be26dada","\u002Fapi\u002Fgrammar_pages\u002F01a1c61d-80e4-78a5-8d8f-40c617cba18b","從情境理解反問嘅立場","睇清楚情境同問句，揀出符合講者意思嘅答案。","word_select",12,"\u002Fuploads\u002Fimages\u002Fgpimg_2dc5caec-f030-47c2-9922-db9348d7e920_hero.webp?v=1794325186",{"@id":135,"@type":126,"id":136,"grammarPage":128,"title":137,"instructions":138,"displayOrder":38,"type":131,"questionCount":132,"blankCount":139,"isCompleted":15,"ogImageUrl":140},"\u002Fapi\u002Fgrammar_exercises\u002F01a1c61d-8930-7d30-bdfb-d921cd4b2daf","01a1c61d-8930-7d30-bdfb-d921cd4b2daf","分清預期答案同未確認嘅前提","按照情境，揀出問句帶出嘅意思，或者符合指定澄清目的嘅回應。",13,"\u002Fuploads\u002Fimages\u002Fgpimg_fb249e8f-980b-41ca-b484-b72e29474e96_hero.webp?v=1794325186",null]