[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"grammar-page-yue-jyukei-batjyu":3,"grammar-exercises-by-page-01a1c61d-823a-7ea2-aca7-c9b980249308":57,"exercise-list-path-yue-none":74},{"id":4,"title":5,"slug":6,"seoDescription":7,"content":8,"language":9,"level":10,"displayOrder":11,"grammarTopics":12,"createdAt":18,"updatedAt":19,"totalExercises":17,"vocabularyLists":20,"readyImages":56},"01a1c61d-823a-7ea2-aca7-c9b980249308","與其不如：取捨","jyukei-batjyu","學識用與其……不如……比較兩個做法，先講較唔理想嘅選擇，再提出更值得做嘅事。掌握兩部分嘅次序、主語位置同否定用法，練習提出建議、表達自己嘅決定同解釋安排。透過等車、買衫同工作嘅日常例子，分清調轉次序之後嘅意思，留意批評語氣，知道幾時要交代人物同理由，以及幾時單用不如就足夠，令取捨講得清楚自然。","## 1. 先講唔揀乜，再講揀乜\n\n當你比較兩個做法，想話其中一個更值得做，就可以用 **與其……不如……**。呢個句式會先講較唔理想嘅選擇，再提出你認為更好嘅做法。你可以用佢提出建議、講自己嘅決定，或者解釋點解要改變安排。\n\n:::example\n大家等咗好耐，架巴士都未到。\n\n**與其**繼續等巴士，**不如**搭地鐵啦。\n\n講嘢嗰個比較「繼續等巴士」同「搭地鐵」，認為搭地鐵更好。\n:::\n\n呢度唔係話等巴士一定錯，而係話：喺而家嘅情況下，搭地鐵更值得考慮。\n\n## 2. 基本句式同主語位置\n\n基本次序係 **與其＋做法甲，不如＋做法乙**。重點放喺後面嘅做法乙；唔好淨係記住兩個做法，要睇清楚邊個擺喺「不如」後面。\n\n| 部分 | 作用 | 例子 |\n| --- | --- | --- |\n| 與其＋做法甲 | 提出較唔理想嘅選擇 | 與其繼續等巴士 |\n| 不如＋做法乙 | 提出較值得採用嘅選擇 | 不如搭地鐵 |\n\n兩個做法由同一個人做，而上下文又清楚講緊邊個，通常唔使重複主語。\n\n:::example\n**我與其**留喺屋企悶，**不如**出去行吓。\n\n**與其我**一個人慢慢諗，**不如**搵你一齊商量。\n:::\n\n兩句都係比較「我」可以採取嘅做法。主語可以放喺「與其」前面，亦可以放喺後面。\n\n如果兩邊由唔同嘅人做，就要交代清楚：\n\n:::example\n你今日好忙，我就得閒。\n\n**與其你**專登送過嚟，**不如我**過去攞啦。\n:::\n\n## 3. 建議、決定同理由\n\n呢個句式唔只用嚟叫人做嘢，亦可以講自己嘅取捨。兩個選擇最好係回應同一個問題，等人明白點解要比較。\n\n- **提出建議：**與其大家喺群組度估，不如直接問負責人啦。\n- **講自己嘅決定：**我與其買幾件平但唔啱着嘅衫，不如買一件真正啱着嘅。\n- **解釋安排：**間餐廳太嘈，與其喺度傾，不如搵個靜啲嘅地方再傾。\n\n理由可以放喺句式前面，先交代情況；亦可以放喺後面，補充點解你覺得第二個做法更好。\n\n:::example\n與其今晚趕住交，不如聽朝檢查清楚先交，因為份表有幾個數字仲未核實。\n:::\n\n:::note\n**與其……不如……**喺當代香港廣東話入面用得自然，尤其適合認真比較做法、提出建議。佢通常比單講「不如……」完整，亦稍為鄭重啲。句末加「啦」可以令建議更似日常對話，但唔代表成句一定客氣。\n:::\n\n## 4. 留意次序、否定同語氣\n\n### 次序一轉，取捨就唔同\n\n| 句子 | 較值得做嘅事 |\n| --- | --- |\n| 與其打電話，不如親身去問。 | 親身去問 |\n| 與其親身去問，不如打電話。 | 打電話 |\n\n兩句文法都啱，但立場唔同。揀邊句，要睇你想推薦邊個做法。\n\n### 唔使額外加否定詞\n\n「與其」本身唔係否定詞。佢後面可以係肯定或者否定嘅做法，要睇你想比較乜。\n\n:::example\n**與其買新嘅，不如修理舊嗰部。**\n\n比較「買新嘅」同「修理舊嗰部」。\n\n**與其唔出聲，不如講清楚你嘅諗法。**\n\n比較「唔出聲」同「講清楚」。\n:::\n\n### 被放棄嘅選擇亦會影響語氣\n\n:::warning\n「與其你喺度嘥時間，不如幫吓手啦」文法冇問題，但「嘥時間」已經帶有批評，對方可能覺得你喺責怪佢。\n\n如果你只係想請對方幫手，可以講：**你而家方唔方便幫吓手呀？** 唔使為咗用呢個句式，刻意將對方而家做緊嘅事講成唔值得做。\n:::\n\n## 5. 揀句式之前，問自己三個問題\n\n1. **我比較緊邊兩個做法？** 兩者應該同眼前嘅問題有關。\n2. **我認為邊個更好？** 將佢放喺「不如」後面。\n3. **我需唔需要講清楚人物同理由？** 如果兩邊做嘢嘅人唔同，或者取捨原因唔明顯，就補充清楚。\n\n:::tip\n記住：**與其先講較唔想揀嘅，不如再講較想揀嘅。** 如果你只想提出一個建議，唔需要明講另一個選擇，單用「不如」就得：**不如搭地鐵啦。**\n:::","yue","B2",124,[13],{"id":14,"name":5,"level":10,"language":9,"isCompleted":15,"completionPercentage":16,"totalExercises":17,"completedExercises":16},"01a1c61d-7fdf-7ea6-826b-7109c896fac1",false,0,2,"2026-11-10T15:39:45+00:00","2026-11-10T17:56:44+00:00",[21],{"id":22,"title":5,"vocabularyListWords":23,"isPublished":37},"01a1c61d-c956-7164-af43-33f0efabbb5d",[24,39],{"id":25,"vocabularyWord":26,"displayOrder":38},"01a1c61d-c956-71c0-af43-33f0f03b03e1",{"id":27,"word":28,"frequency":29,"level":30,"language":9,"partsOfSpeech":31,"audio":15},"01a1c61d-a9b4-7454-bdbd-96a23bc43a13","與其",7,"B1",[32],{"id":33,"partOfSpeech":34,"definition":35,"exampleSentences":36,"isPrimary":37,"meaningOrder":38},"01a1c696-322a-7d53-847b-6ff6c23ce041","CONJUNCTION","用嚟比較兩個選擇，表示喺兩樣嘢之中，覺得後面嗰樣好啲、更值得揀，通常同「不如」或者「寧願」一齊用。「與其」後面帶出嘅係冇咁好、被放棄嘅一邊。","與其喺屋企閒閒哋，不如出去行下。\n與其搭巴士塞車，我寧願行路去。\n佢話與其月月都搬嘢，不如一次過買層樓。",true,1,{"id":40,"vocabularyWord":41,"displayOrder":17},"01a1c61d-c956-71f0-af43-33f0f124d1b8",{"id":42,"word":43,"frequency":44,"level":45,"language":9,"partsOfSpeech":46,"audio":15},"01a1c61d-a838-7397-aa7b-77d2b81f2452","不如",9,"A2",[47,51],{"id":48,"partOfSpeech":34,"definition":49,"exampleSentences":50,"isPrimary":37,"meaningOrder":38},"01a1c696-2e71-77be-a86a-fc394d95d135","用嚟提出一個更好嘅建議，意思係「不如我哋做呢樣，會好啲」，通常用喺講緊建議嘅時候。","今日好熱，不如我哋去游水啦。\n出面落緊雨，不如留喺屋企睇戲。\n你咁攰，不如早啲瞓覺。",{"id":52,"partOfSpeech":53,"definition":54,"exampleSentences":55,"isPrimary":15,"meaningOrder":17},"01a1c696-2e71-780a-a86a-fc394e5d59ed","VERB","用嚟比較兩樣嘢，表示前面嗰樣唔及後面嗰樣好，即係「比唔上」。","我嘅廣東話不如你好。\n網上買嘢不如喺舖頭買放心。\n呢間餐廳嘅嘢食不如嗰間好食。",[],[58,68],{"@id":59,"@type":60,"id":61,"grammarPage":62,"title":63,"instructions":64,"displayOrder":16,"type":65,"questionCount":66,"blankCount":66,"isCompleted":15,"ogImageUrl":67},"\u002Fapi\u002Fgrammar_exercises\u002F01a1c61d-95b5-7e5e-8a37-26c32c154167","GrammarExercise","01a1c61d-95b5-7e5e-8a37-26c32c154167","\u002Fapi\u002Fgrammar_pages\u002F01a1c61d-823a-7ea2-aca7-c9b980249308","先講放棄，再講選擇","按照每題講明嘅決定，揀出意思吻合嘅選項。留意兩個做法嘅次序同做嘢嘅人。","word_select",12,"\u002Fuploads\u002Fimages\u002Fgpimg_defdcef9-1ec2-487c-b1c0-6553c27cc05c_hero.webp?v=1794325190",{"@id":69,"@type":60,"id":70,"grammarPage":62,"title":71,"instructions":72,"displayOrder":38,"type":65,"questionCount":66,"blankCount":66,"isCompleted":15,"ogImageUrl":73},"\u002Fapi\u002Fgrammar_exercises\u002F01a1c61d-95ce-7d64-8b56-64c1fd6dc6d9","01a1c61d-95ce-7d64-8b56-64c1fd6dc6d9","按情境表達取捨同語氣","睇清楚人物想比較乜、推薦乜同用咩語氣，再揀出符合要求嘅選項。","\u002Fuploads\u002Fimages\u002Fgpimg_4d876971-fe2d-46dc-9eea-7b6afe75b66f_hero.webp?v=1794325190",null]